benny’s bagels

Home of the Milwaukee Bagel


Benny’s Bagels is on a mission to build community through food.


Milwaukee, WI

City of Makers

(and carb-lovers)

Benny’s Bagels has made the first ever Milwaukee Bagel - a bagel that’s boiled and baked and served fresh out of the oven, chewy on the inside and crisp on the outside. We mix things up with high-quality ingredients and compelling flavor combinations. Our intent is to honor Milwaukee’s rich history as a city of makers and foster community around made-from-scratch bagels.

Benny’s Bagels currently sells from our home in the Brady Street neighborhood, and we have dreams to sell at farmers markets, food trucks, and eventually, from a storefront that brings Milwaukeeans together.


IMG_5533 (2).jpg

Taking custom orders for private events, corporate meetings, open houses, fundraisers… whatever!

Name *
Let us know what you need bagels for, the number and type, and when you need 'em! (At least a week's notice is best.)