Benny’s Bagels makes an authentic bagel: an old world-style bagel that’s not too dough-y, not too sweet, full of flavor, chewy, with a crisp exterior that we’ve spent countless hours perfecting.

 
 

MILWAUKEE, WI

CITY OF MAKERS

(AND CARB-LOVERS)

Benny’s Bagels is the first authentic bagel shop in Milwaukee - we provide the kind that are boiled and baked and served fresh out of the oven. Our mission is to honor Milwaukee’s rich history as a city of makers and create community around made-from-scratch bagels.

Benny’s Bagels currently sells from a home in the Brady Street neighborhood, but we have dreams to sell at farmers markets, out of a food truck, and eventually, from a storefront that brings Milwaukeeans together.